x Abu Dhabi, UAEMonday 22 January 2018

Qaddafi’s son misses one hearing while another is postponed

Saif Al Islam Qaddafi, the most prominent figure of his father’s regime, is expected to be charged for his alleged role in killings during the eight-month civil war in 2011.

TRIPOLI // The son of Libya’s former dictator Muammar Qaddafi missed a court hearing yesterday after the militia holding him refused to send him to the capital, underscoring the continued weakness of the central government after the country’s civil war.

Saif Al Islam Qaddafi, the most prominent figure of his father’s regime, appeared for a separate hearing instead in the western town of Zintan, where a militia has held him since the end of the war. The slim, bearded Saif stood and sat at times in a cage inside the courtroom, wearing a blue prison uniform.

A judge there adjourned the trial until December 12 over a lack of evidence.

Al Seddik Al Sur of the state prosecutor’s office told reporters yesterday that authorities have asked for “justification” as to why Saif was not transferred from Zintan as planned.

The Tripoli trial involves 38 former regime officials, including notorious spymaster Abdullah Al Senoussi, but only 36 were in attendance. In addition to Saif, another unidentified defendant was not there.

Yesterday’s hearing was to present the prosecutors’ case to the judge who will then evaluate its merits and possibly order more investigations before setting the official charges. The charges are expected to revolve around the killings during the eight-month civil war in 2011.

At least a dozen men sat in blue prison uniforms in a row behind bars surrounded by baseball cap-wearing security guards in the Tripoli courtroom. The court itself was otherwise empty.

A few dozen people protested outside the courthouse, mostly family members of those who died during the war as well as during the years of Muammar Qaddafi’s rule. Women carried portraits of their dead sons while others plastered pictures of them on the building’s fence.

Saif, the only member of the family to go on trial so far, faces charges from the Zintan militia that captured him as he was trying to flee south to Niger.

International institutions and rights groups have criticised the trial conditions he faces.

“Our main concern is he is still being held by a militia in Zintan outside the authority of the state,” said Hanan Salah, who follows the case for Human Rights Watch.

She said the situation for Saif was indicative of the shortcomings of justice in Libya in general, where due process is often not followed, lawyers have been intimidated and detention facilities are poorly supervised.

“In general, we have concerns over the facilities that are not under the full custody of the state. This is where we have documented serious abuses,” she said, adding that Saif has yet to see a lawyer for the Tripoli-based trial.

He did have a lawyer for his future case in front of the International Criminal Court, but she was detained after her second meeting with him in Zintan on charges of trying to smuggle documents and a camera to him.

Magda Mughrabi, a researcher for Amnesty International who met Saif on September 9, described the refusal to give up Qaddafi’s son as typical of the power struggle between the central government and the militias. She said it happens daily with other detainees.

“Militias use valid arguments that this is driven by security considerations and that it is not safe to hand him to Tripoli,” she said. “It might be actually true in a sense but the wider problem is the fact that there is a weak government and different militias are using the security vacuum and current lawlessness in asserting their control to challenge the authority.”

Successive Libyan governments have failed to impose law and order in the country since rebel forces overthrew Qaddafi and killed him. Authorities instead rely on heavily armed militia groups, initially drawn from the rebellion, for security, although some began challenging the central government as it struggles with a transition to democracy.

Qaddafi’s son and the spy chief are wanted by the International Criminal Court on charges of murder and the persecution of civilians during the early days of the uprising. If convicted there, they would face a maximum sentence of life imprisonment. The ICC does not recognise the death penalty.

This summer, judges from The Hague court ruled that Libya cannot give Qaddafi’s son a fair trial and asked authorities to hand him over.

Associated Press