Court rules US student barred in boycott case can stay in Israel
Lara Alqasem was president of a local chapter of Students for Justice in Palestine
An American student barred from entering Israel under a law against foreign activists who support boycotts of the state over its Palestinian policies was given permission to stay in the country by the Supreme Court on Thursday.
In its ruling, the court criticised the Israeli authorities for denying entry to Lara Alqasem, 22, saying their decision gave “the unavoidable impression” that she was barred for her political opinions.
If so, the justices said, it represented “a radical and dangerous step that could lead to the crumbling of the foundations upon which Israel’s democracy is built”.
Ms Alqasem was refused entry when she flew to Israel on a study visa on October 2. Security officials cited her role as president of a small local chapter of Students for Justice in Palestine at the University of Florida.
Her case touched off a debate in Israel over whether democratic values had been compromised by a 2017 law that bars the entry of foreigners who publicly support boycotts over Israel’s policies towards the Palestinians.
Thursday’s ruling, seen by Reuters, overturned a lower court decision that had backed the decision by Israeli authorities.
Ms Alqasem said she was relieved by the court’s decision and would speak more later. Her lawyers called the ruling “a victory for free speech, academic freedom, and the rule of law”.
Public security minister Gilad Erdan, who had denied Ms Alqasem entry, said the government would look into the implications of the ruling.
“We will examine the legal criteria in order to ensure that the original intent of the law is maintained,” he said. “The principle that whoever acts to harm the State of Israel and its citizens should be refused entry must be preserved.”
Members of Israel’s right-wing government have long criticised the court for being, in their eyes, too liberal in its interventions regarding policy towards Palestinians.
The Supreme Court accepted Ms Alqasem’s lawyers’ argument that she had ceased her pro-boycott activity in April 2017, and noted that since then she had engaged in Holocaust studies and had been accepted to a postgraduate programme at Jerusalem’s Hebrew University, which supported her petition.
“Since the petitioner’s actions do not sufficiently warrant banning her entry to Israel, the unavoidable impression is that her political opinions were the reason behind the cancellation of the visa that was granted to her,” the ruling said.
“If that is indeed the case, we are talking about a radical and dangerous step.”
The court cited in its decision Hebrew University’s contention that barring the entry, at the airport, of a foreign student accepted into an international programme damaged the college's international ties.
However one justice wrote that if Ms Alqasem “returns to her old ways” and promoted a boycott while she is in Israel, her stay could be cancelled and she could be expelled.
It was not immediately clear whether the Israeli authorities would appeal the ruling.
Updated: October 20, 2018 04:25 PM