A German man is sentenced to life in prison for fatally stabbing a pregnant Egyptian woman in a Dresden court.
Man convicted of Egyptian woman's court killing
DRESDEN, GERMANY // A Russian-born German man has been found guilty of murder and sentenced to life in prison for fatally stabbing a pregnant Egyptian woman in court, an attack that triggered outrage in the Muslim world. The Dresden state court said in its ruling Wednesday that because of the particularly brutal nature of the crime defendant Alexander Wiens, 28, would not be eligible for early release.
During the trial, Wiens admitted stabbing Marwa al Sherbini to death at a July 1 court hearing in Dresden. Wiens had argued, however, that his actions were not premeditated and that he had no xenophobic motivation. His attorneys had sought a lesser manslaughter conviction and said they would appeal the verdict. Maria Boehmer, the German government official responsible for immigrant affairs, said the verdict was "an important signal for the people of Egypt and other parts of the Arab world."
"The message is: There is no place for xenophobia in our country," she said. During a trip to London, German Foreign Minister and Vice Chancellor Guido Westerwelle said he welcomed the conviction. "It makes it very clear that violence, that racial intolerance and hatred, have no place in Germany," he told reporters at the Foreign Ministry. Mrs al Sherbini, a 31-year-old pharmacist, was stabbed at least 16 times by Wiens in the Dresden courtroom where she was to testify against him. She had filed a complaint against him in 2008, accusing him of insulting her with racial slurs, calling her a "terrorist" and "Islamist" during an altercation. Many German courts, including the one where the killing took place, have no security checks at their entrance. Prosecutors said the defendant used a kitchen knife with an 18-centimetre blade that he had brought into the courtroom in a backpack.
Her husband, a scientist conducting research in Dresden, was stabbed and suffered serious injuries when he intervened to protect her. The couple's three-year-old son was in the courtroom and witnessed the attack. About 1,500 demonstrators outside the courtroom ahead of the verdict carried signs with slogans like "stop the Islam hate in Germany" and "the death of Marwa is the result of Islam hunting".
In addition to murder, Wiens was convicted of attempted murder for his attack on Mrs al Sherbini's husband, Elwy Okaz. Presiding Judge Birgit Wiegand said the court was not influenced by the intense international interest in the case. "We did not pronounce the verdict for the Muslims or any other group, we pronounced the verdict according to German justice - like we would against any other defendant," she said.
"He murdered Marwa al-Sherbini before the eyes of her child," Ms Wiegand said. Though Wiens' sentence was the harshest possible under the German system - most condemned to life in prison are eligible for release after 15 years - people in the victim's hometown of Alexandria, Egypt, said it was not enough. "She died, but he's still alive," said neighbour Badr Shorbagy, 57. Egyptian Ambassador Ramzy Ezzeldin Ramzy told reporters outside the courtroom, however, that he thought "justice has been honoured."
"Getting the maximum possible sentence, I think that itself says a lot," he said. In his closing arguments on Monday, prosecutor Frank Heinrich said there was no doubt of Wiens' reasons. "It's clear that his motive was hatred for Muslims," Heinrich told the panel of judges. "Like a maniacal, cold-blooded killer, he started stabbing the woman and her husband, who was trying to protect her." When given an opportunity to respond in court Tuesday, Wiens declined to comment.
"I don't want to say anything," he told the court. Wiens, a German citizen, was born in the Russian city of Perm and has lived in Germany since late 2003. Egyptians expressed outrage at the attack and an initially low-key German response, which many viewed as a sign of racism and anti-Muslim sentiment. The week after the killing, German Chancellor Angela Merkel expressed her condolences to Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak but did not comment publicly.