Abu Dhabi, UAEWednesday 17 July 2019

Accuser denounces pope's silence over abuse cover-up claims

Archbishop Vigano says he has proof of Vatican cover-up of sexual misconduct by ex-cardinal McCarrick

Ex-cardinal Theodore McCarrick prays during the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops' annual fall assembly in Baltimore. AP
Ex-cardinal Theodore McCarrick prays during the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops' annual fall assembly in Baltimore. AP

The former Vatican ambassador who accused three popes and their advisers of covering up for a disgraced American ex-cardinal has denounced Pope Francis' refusal to directly respond to his claims and challenged the Vatican to say what it knows about the scandal.

Archbishop Carlo Maria Vigano penned a new missive a month after his initial 11-page bombshell sent shockwaves through the Catholic Church. It was uploaded to a document-sharing site late on Thursday.

In the document, Mr Vigano denounced the official Vatican silence about his claims and accused Pope Francis of mounting a campaign of "subtle slander" against him by referring indirectly to him as Satan in recent homilies. Mr Vigano urged the current head of the Vatican bishops office to speak out, saying he has all the documentation needed to prove years of cover-up by the Vatican about alleged sexual misconduct by ex-Cardinal Theodore McCarrick.

"How can one avoid concluding that the reason they do not provide the documentation is that they know it confirms my testimony?" Mr Vigano wrote. "The pope's unwillingness to respond to my charges and his deafness to the appeals by the faithful for accountability are hardly consistent with his calls for transparency and bridge building."


Read more:

Pope meets with US church leaders over clergy sex abuse

Vatican fights back against accusations of sex abuse cover-up

Pope says he will not respond to allegations of abuse cover-up


The letter was dated Friday, 29 September, the feast of St. Michael, Archangel. It was not a coincidence: St. Michael is considered the protector of the church, the leader of all angels who battled evil and drove it from the church.

Mr Vigano threw Pope Francis' papacy into turmoil last month when he accused him of rehabilitating McCarrick from sanctions imposed by Pope Benedict XVI. He accused more than two dozen current and former Vatican officials, as well as a host of US bishops and papal advisers, of being part of the cover-up and called for the pontiff to resign over the scandal.

The Vatican has known since at least 2000 that McCarrick would invite seminarians to his New Jersey beach house and into his bed. And yet St. John Paul II made him archbishop of Washington and a cardinal in 2001, and McCarrick became a spokesman for the US bishops in 2002 as they sought to address the then-burgeoning sexual abuse scandal that had erupted that year in Boston.

Pope Francis removed McCarrick as a cardinal in July after a US church investigation determined an allegation he sexually abused a teenage altar boy in the 1970s was credible. After news broke of the investigation, several former seminarians and priests came forward to report that they, too, had been abused or harassed by McCarrick as adults. The scandal has led to a crisis in confidence in both the US and Vatican hierarchy, since McCarrick's sexual escapades were apparently an open secret in some US church circles.

In his first denunciation, published 26 August, Mr Vigano initially claimed former pope Benedict had imposed sanctions against McCarrick prohibiting him from exercising public ministry, travelling or lecturing on behalf of the church. He has changed his account, however, since the historic record is rife with evidence McCarrick lived his ministry free from any real constraints, and it is unclear what type of sanctions were ever imposed.

But the crux of Mr Vigano's claim was that he told Pope Francis of the sanctions against McCarrick on 23 June 2013, and that the pope effectively rehabilitated McCarrick and made him a trusted adviser.

Updated: September 28, 2018 09:45 AM