Home-grown doctors are returning from the US and Europe as India's health care capital, Chennai, develops into a top budget destination for medical tourists.
Brain regain in India as medical tourism booms
CHENNAI, India // One of the multitude of Indian emigrant doctors, Paul Ramesh moved to Britain in the 1990s, keen to get the best surgical training and earn a generous pay packet.
Today he is still treating Westerners, but in hospital beds back in Chennai, his hometown in Tamil Nadu state.
“When I came back it was quite exceptional to return. Now it’s the rule,” the 46-year-old said at the city’s Apollo hospital, soon after performing a heart transplant on a woman from the United States.
In Chennai, known as India’s health care capital, medical workers describe a “reverse brain drain” as home-grown doctors return from the US and Europe – at the same time as the city develops as a top budget destination for medical tourists.
While the number of Indian doctors abroad remains substantial, Apollo staff say their national hospital chain now gets 300 applications annually from those working in Britain alone, encouraged by improved living standards and better medical technology at home.
Traditionally drawn to the West to boost their expertise and earnings, doctors also cited tightening salaries under Britain’s National Health Service and increasingly tough US healthcare regulations as factors luring them back.
“The trend is reversing,” said M Balasubramanian, president of the Indian Medical Association in Tamil Nadu.
“More corporate hospitals are coming up, especially in Chennai. Now [doctors] have an opportunity to use their expertise in their own place ... and pull the patients from abroad also.”
Inside the Apollo, with a lobby bustling more like a marketplace than a typical hospital, KP Kosygan has just carried out a double knee replacement on an elderly Kenyan patient.
The consultant orthopaedic surgeon came back from Britain in 2011 and said there was “a regular stream of doctors coming back”.
“Certainly when I left India there were not many joint replacement centres or surgeons in India who could train us,” he said.
Now doctors want to “share our experience we have gained across the globe”, he said, adding that many were also pulled back to look after ageing parents, in a country where family ties are paramount.
As well as treating Indians, Dr Kosygan said he now treats patients “from almost every corner of the world” who are drawn by the cheap costs.
Patients Beyond Borders, a US medical travel resource, says the cost of certain Indian medical procedures can be up to 90 per cent lower than in the United States, making it one of the cheapest places for treatment.
While most patients come to India from the Middle East, Africa and other parts of Asia, interest from America is growing, said Patients Beyond Borders chief executive Josef Woodman.
“On a heart operation they can save $50,000 [Dh183,500] to $70,000,” he said.
At Apollo, a dedicated “international patients” area has clocks on the wall showing times in cities including New York and Tokyo while translators are present to deal with foreign arrivals who number about 70,000 a year.
Many patients come from countries “where they do really require quality expertise at a more affordable price”, said Anto Sahayaraj, 42, who returned from New Zealand in 2012 to work at the Frontier Lifeline Hospital in Chennai.
After performing a heart procedure on a one-month-old baby from Bahrain, the specialist in paediatric cardiac surgery said foreign patients were encouraged by Indian doctors’ overseas experience.
“They see a lot of Indians in Western countries and they realise that some of us do come back. With us technology comes back, so they have increasing confidence.”
For all India’s advances on the global stage, doctors emphasised ways in which the country’s healthcare system is still sorely lagging.
N Ragavan, a consultant uro-oncologist specialising in prostate cancer, returned to India from Britain last year and pointed out the “million-dollar difference” between the two countries.
While Britain enjoys universal healthcare coverage, many Indians struggle to pay for quality private treatment, while public services are poorly funded and governed.
“Financial affordability is the biggest problem that India faces,” said Dr Ragavan, 41, who hopes the country’s low health insurance cover will grow substantially over the next decade.
He said the benefits of working in one of India’s corporate hospitals include speedy medical investigations and hardly any waiting lists, but the lack of working directives means he is now at the hospital for up to 17-hour days.
“Working in India is a double-edged sword,” he said.
“It’s never organised here. What I’m going to do next week is not sure, and what I’m going to do this week is very chaotic.”
* Agence France-Presse