Killers lose their appeal against death sentence
DUBAI // Two men who were found guilty of murdering a prostitute in 2010 had their original death sentences upheld yesterday by the Court of Appeal.
AA, 40 and IH, 30, both from Afghanistan, had their sentences overturned by the Court of Cassation on August 15.
The court ordered a retrial in light of the defence argument that the death was accidental.
But a new panel of judges, led by Chief Justice Issa Al Sharif of the appellate court, reviewed the case and issued a guilty verdict. They ruled that the killing was premeditated.
Prosecution records show that AA was romantically involved with the victim, the Uzbek MH, while IH allegedly met her for the first time on the evening of her murder.
MH's flatmate, NA, 42, also a prostitute, was sentenced to six months in jail and has been deported since the initial court's judgement. But she told prosecutors AA and IH came to their apartment in February 2010 and had sex with her and the victim.
She said AA came to them that day upset because he believed MH was sleeping with many other Afghan men.
NA testified that she heard MH being killed, but was unable to help as IH repeatedly punched her and locked her in the bathroom.
MH was stabbed 23 times by the two men. The men also stole Dh600, two mobile phones, a DVD player and perfumes, records show. DNA evidence linked AA and IH to the crime scene.
"I intended to rob her. We fought and I unintentionally killed her. I did not preplan the crime," AA told the court of appeals at an earlier hearing.