Abu Dhabi, UAETuesday 21 May 2019

Joe Root plays down England's batting concerns after crushing Test defeat to South Africa

Hosts collapse to 340-run loss following consecutive batting failures in second Test against Proteas at Trent Bridge.

South Africa's Vernon Philander celebrates the wicket of England's Ben Stokes with his teammates at Trent Bridge on Monday. Carl Recine / Reuters
South Africa's Vernon Philander celebrates the wicket of England's Ben Stokes with his teammates at Trent Bridge on Monday. Carl Recine / Reuters

England captain Joe Root played down concerns over his side's misfiring top order after a comprehensive, series-levelling defeat to South Africa but kept the door open for changes ahead of the third Test.

After kicking off his reign with a handsome victory at Lord's, Root saw his team humbled at Trent Bridge where they were skittled for 133 in 44.2 overs for a 340-run defeat.

Doubts over opener Keaton Jennings and Root's Yorkshire teammate Gary Ballance are growing rather than receding with each innings, with the pair making 44 and 85 respectively in four knocks apiece.

Ballance's crease-bound technique has been exposed again on his third coming as a Test batsman, while Jennings's dismissal by Vernon Philander for three, was unedifying indeed.

Root provided some support for the pair in post-match presentation, but hinted their positions were not guaranteed for the Oval Test.

"No, I don't think it [the top three] is a concern. They just need some runs and to spend some time out in the middle," he told Sky Sports 2. "I'm sure if they get the opportunity to do that in the next game they will go on and make big scores.

"We'll sit down with selection and make sure we're happy with what we have going into the next one."

Another player potentially looking over his shoulder is paceman Mark Wood.

The Durham player returned to the red-ball setup after a two-year injury-enforced absence at the start of this series but has managed just one wicket for 197 runs in two Tests.

Bowling coach Ottis Gibson suggested he had experienced some discomfort in his heel - not his troublesome ankle - but Root is hoping that issue does not develop.

"It's been a tough week for Woody, really," he said. "He worked really hard throughout the game and was unfortunate not to pick up many wickets but I can't fault his efforts, the way he's gone about it.

"In terms of fitness he came through quite well, so hopefully he's fit for selection for the next one."

Set a world-record target of 474 in a match dominated by the tourists from the start of Day 2, England never got going despite perfect conditions under cloudless skies - and were bowled out before tea for a flaky 133.

After falling well short by their own admission of required standards in the first innings, too, Root's team had lost all 20 wickets in 96.1 overs as South Africa emphatically levelled the four-match series at 1-1.

Vernon Philander (3-24) made two early breakthroughs - and after Chris Morris then removed both captain Root and his predecessor Alastair Cook, realistic hopes of seriously extending South Africa were already fading fast on 79-4 at lunch.

Their descent to defeat was in unstoppable mode, but it was still mildly surprising that they continued to subside so quickly in an error-strewn afternoon as Keshav Maharaj (3-42) took his match haul to six wickets.

England's two out-of-form left-handers Jennings and Ballance had proved no match for Philander, who saw them off with the new ball for a combined seven runs.

Jennings left a big gap between bat and pad, pushing forward, and lost his off-stump. Then Ballance succumbed lbw when Philander's review, after an initial not-out decision, demonstrated the ball pitched on leg-stump and straightened enough off the pitch to hit it.

Also read:

Paul Radley: Why players such as Rabada should be cut some slack

Cook, who had to overturn an lbw decision the previous evening to avoid a golden duck to the first ball of the innings, took 22 balls to get off the mark and a fair bit longer to locate the middle of the bat.

But he appeared in no mood to go quietly - even after England's prospects had taken a huge dent at the other end when Root lost his off-stump to an unstoppable, outswinging yorker from Morris.

South Africa celebrated like a team who knew already they had victory in their sights.

Cussed Cook stood in their way, but Morris had a delivery to do for him, too.

A brilliant bouncer had the normally unflappable opener in a proper tangle - and as he bailed out of an involuntary hook, he gloved the ball fine down the leg-side where wicketkeeper Quinton de Kock completed a high-class dismissal with wonderful reactions to take a diving catch.

Jonny Bairstow's departure straight after lunch was less hard-won, England's wicketkeeper choosing an acceptable attacking option - up the pitch to try to hit Keshav Maharaj over mid-on - but making a hash of it and planting the ball into the hands of the fielder.

Moeen Ali's similar intent brought only brief success before he mistimed a sweep at Maharaj to square-leg - one of several men waiting for his mistake on that specific shot - and when Philander pulled off a neat caught-and-bowled to see off Ben Stokes in the next over, it was merely a matter of how long the England tail could delay the inevitable.

There turned out to be precious little by way of late defiance, the last five wickets falling in a heap for only 11 runs - and the previously unsuccessful Duanne Olivier finishing with numbers 10 and 11 in successive balls.

That confirmed the downward spiral but had no further relevance - because the damage had long been done, not just in a whimpering second innings but in the misplaced adventure of the first too against a pedigree touring attack that will surely demand significant respect for the remainder of the series.

Updated: July 17, 2017 06:31 PM



Editor's Picks