Abu Dhabi, UAESaturday 21 September 2019

Japan's Kobe Steel slides further into mire as data scandal spreads

Loses clients with falsiification discovery now embracing mainstream steel business

Kobe Steel's executive vice president Naoto Umehara (C) bows in apology with other executives as investigations into falsified data on its products widened. AP/Muneyoshi Someya
Kobe Steel's executive vice president Naoto Umehara (C) bows in apology with other executives as investigations into falsified data on its products widened. AP/Muneyoshi Someya

Kobe Steel sank deeper into crisis on Friday as the embattled Japanese company said it had lost some customers to competitors because of widespread data falsification that had extended to its mainstream steel sheet business.

Japan's third-largest steel maker, which supplies the world's top airlines and automobile manufacturers, also said it had violated statutory standards set by the industry ministry, pushing the scandal beyond failure to meet specifications agreed with customers.

Until now, the 112-year-old company had said products it sold with falsified data met safety and other standards but did not meet contract specifications agreed with customers. It had also said the problem was mainly with aluminium and copper products.

Kobe Steel has an extensive role in global supply chains - the company produces engine valve springs found in half the world's cars, according to its website.

The Kobe Steel executive vice president Naoto Umehara said the company had found a breach of industrial standards at its Hatano copper plant south-west of Tokyo, along with a new case of falsification of data at a unit that cuts and processes steel plate.

"There has been also some impact on our business as we have lost credibility,” Mr Umehara said, citing cases that the company lost orders and customers switched to its competitors. "But we can’t quantify the impact at the moment."

He said the Hatano plant did not meet Japanese industrial standards for quality management after it faked data on tensile strength and other properties of copper and copper-alloy piping.

Kobe Steel has stopped shipping about 43 per cent of copper products from the plant over the problems with the statutory standards, a company spokeswoman said.

Two certification companies said on Thursday they were investigating whether the plant is in line with a global standard on quality control.

They could suspend or cancel the "ISO9001" certification of the plant if it does not meet the standard, which could affect its business as many global buyers require suppliers to use the benchmark.


Read more:

Toyota declares aluminium from scandal hit Kobe is safe

Corporate scandals drag Japan Inc's reputation through the mud

Japanese steel major admits falsifying quality data


Kobe Steel said it also found, as the result of a whistleblower, that a plant in western Japan had been "obstructing company’s voluntary inspection” by concealing data.

After getting a tip that workers at the Chofu plant failed to report data falsification on aluminium extrusion products, the company decided to set up a panel of outsiders, replacing an in-house panel led by the company’s president.

The ministry of trade and Industry believes "the data concealment by its employees has hurt the credibility of Kobe Steel’s voluntary investigation", said Yasuji Komiyama, director of the industry ministry’s metal industries division.

The ministry ordered the company on Friday to expedite its probes and report results as soon as possible.

Kobe Steel previously said that it found widespread falsification of data on the strength and durability of copper and aluminium products sent to customers. The falsifications stretch back for more than 10 years, a senior executive said last week.

Global car makers, aircraft companies and other manufacturers have scrambled to identify potential hazards in their products because of the falsification, although four Japanese car makers said on Thursday they have found no safety issues with aluminium parts supplied by Kobe Steel.

The company is now subject to a US justice department probe while checks continue at hundreds of its clients involved in complex supply chains spanning the globe.

No safety problems have surfaced as Kobe Steel attempts to confirm the extent of the data tampering. But in Europe, aviation safety authorities last week issued a directive advising aircraft manufacturers to avoid using Kobe Steel products if they can until checks are completed.

"We are worried about the US justice department probe," said a source at one of the company's lenders. "The impact will be very big if the DOJ seeks a criminal case against Kobe and hits it with huge financial penalties."

The company has started selling assets to raise funds, on Friday holding the first round of an auction to sell its most of a property unit, sources said, a deal that reportedly could raise over US$400 million.

Kobe Steel's fate hangs in the balance while checks are being carried out.

Its shares fell 1.6 per cent on Friday. They have fallen nearly 40 per cent since it revealed the problems on October 8, wiping about US$1.6 billion off its market value.

Updated: October 21, 2017 12:28 PM