Abu Dhabi, UAETuesday 22 October 2019

Airlines to be ordered to follow Boeing safety advice after Lion Air tragedy

Fatal Lion Air crash of 737 Max off Indonesian coast spurs Federal Aviation Authority to enforce bulletin directive on how to handle false cockpit readings

epa07136191 Indonesian rescuers sort recovered debris of Lion Air flight JT610 before loading onto a truck for investigation by the National Transportation Safety Committee at Tanjung Priok port in Jakarta, Indonesia, 02 November 2018. Lion Air flight JT-610 lost contact with air traffic controllers soon after takeoff then crashed into the sea on 29 October. The flight was en route to Pangkal Pinang, and reportedly had 189 people onboard. EPA/MAST IRHAM
epa07136191 Indonesian rescuers sort recovered debris of Lion Air flight JT610 before loading onto a truck for investigation by the National Transportation Safety Committee at Tanjung Priok port in Jakarta, Indonesia, 02 November 2018. Lion Air flight JT-610 lost contact with air traffic controllers soon after takeoff then crashed into the sea on 29 October. The flight was en route to Pangkal Pinang, and reportedly had 189 people onboard. EPA/MAST IRHAM

US aviation regulators plan to order airlines to follow Boeing’s advisory on how pilots should handle false readings from a plane sensor that authorities linked to last week’s deadly 737 Max jet crash off the coast of Indonesia.

The Boeing bulletin combined with statements by Indonesian investigators suggest that the pilots on the Lion Air 737 Max 8 were battling the plane as its computers commanded a steep dive. The issue is easily solved - Boeing’s notice said crews should follow an existing procedure to combat it - but can be difficult to address if pilots become confused.

The so called angle-of-attack sensor failed on Lion Air Flight 610 and had been replaced the previous day after earlier faults, the Indonesia National Transportation Safety Committee said in a briefing. The malfunction can cause the plane’s computers to erroneously register an aerodynamic stall, causing the aircraft to abruptly dive to regain the airspeed it needs to keep flying.

The US Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) last week said it would issue an airworthiness directive on the issue and “will take further appropriate actions depending on the results of the investigation”. The FAA also notified regulatory counterparts around the world, which typically follow the US agency’s lead on safety matters.

The Boeing bulletin only reminds operators of the plane to follow existing procedures and doesn’t require any physical fixes that could disrupt service. It’s still possible the FAA may order the Chicago-based plane maker to redesign the Max’s flight computers in the wake of the October 29 accident, which left 189 people dead.

JAKARTA, INDONESIA - NOVEMBER 05: Families of victims of Lion Air flight JT 610 weeps as they meeting with authorities and Lion Air management on November 5, 2018 in Jakarta, Indonesia. Indonesian officials said they have downloaded the data from a black box recorder for Lion Air flight 610 which crashed into Java sea last week while at least 105 body bags containing parts of passengers have been handed to the national police hospital in Jakarta for identification. All 189 passengers and crew for the Boeing 737 are feared dead after the plane crashed shortly after takeoff as investigators and agencies from around the world continue its week-long search for the main wreckage and cockpit voice recorder which might solve the mystery. (Photo by Ulet Ifansasti/Getty Images)
Families of victims of Lion Air flight JT 610. Getty

The Lion Air jetliner plunged into the Java Sea minutes after takeoff from Jakarta airport, nosing downward so suddenly that it may have hit speeds of 950kph before slamming into the water, Bloomberg said.

Moments earlier, the pilots radioed a request to return to Jakarta to land, but never turned back toward the airport, according to Indonesia’s National Transportation Safety Committee and flight-tracking data. The committee said the pilots were dealing with an erroneous airspeed indication.

Boeing said it is cooperating fully and providing technical assistance as the investigation continues.

Indonesia authorities said on Saturday they had stopped the search for victims of the crash but would keep looking for the Lion Air flight's second black box, the cockpit voice recorder.

"There is nowhere left to search and we have stopped finding victims' bodies," Muhammad Syaugi, the head of the national search and rescue agency (Basarnas) told Reuters. "We will limit our operations to monitoring."

Authorities have downloaded data from one of the black boxes found last week, the flight data recorder, but are still looking for the cockpit voice recorder.

Soearjanto Tjahjono, the head of the transportation safety committee (KNKT), said finding the voice recorder would be critical to understanding the cause of the crash.

"From the black box data, we know about 70 to 80 per cent of what happened but to 100 per cent understand the cause of the accident ... we need be able to know the conversation that took place in the plane's cockpit," he said, declining to elaborate on what the flight data recorder had revealed.

He said authorities were searching for 15 aircraft parts, including an "angle of attack" sensor on the aircraft, which helps the plane's computers understand if the aircraft is stable. Investigators have said one of these sensors had provided erroneous data.

An wrong angle-of-attack reading while pilots are flying manually can cause the plane’s flight computers to command the Max models to dive, Boeing said in the bulletin to airlines. While planes like the Max fly mostly on autopilot, pilots can fly manually if they’re dealing with unusual situations like the malfunctions that occurred on the Lion Air flight.

Pilots can override the nose-down movement by pushing a switch on their control yoke, but the plane’s computers will resume trying to dive as soon as they release the switch, the manufacturer said.


Read more:

About the 737 Max: the plane at the centre of the Lion Air crash

Lion Air plane rips wing on take-off in troubling times for low-cost carrier


Pilots should follow a separate procedure to halt the potentially dangerous action by the plane, the bulletin said. Flight crews are taught to handle “uncommanded nose-down stabiliser trim” by memorising a procedure to disengage the angle-of-attack inputs to the plane’s computer system.

That angle-of-attack sensor is intended to measure the direction of air flow over wings so that they maintain lift. If the flow is disrupted by a plane going too slow or climbing too steeply, that can cause an aerodynamic stall and a plane will plummet. However, if the sensor malfunctions, it can cause the plane’s computers to erroneously think it is in a stall - which can then command the aircraft to abruptly dive.

The jet reported a discrepancy in its angle of attack sensor during a flight from Bali to Jakarta the day before it crashed. The device was replaced after pilots reported a problem with the airspeed reading, the Indonesian transportation safety regulator said on Wednesday.

Aviators say Boeing training manual did not mention problem that may have downed Lion Air passenger jet. AP
A Lion Air passenger jet. AP

Boeing has delivered 219 Max planes - the latest and most advanced 737 jets - since the models made their commercial debut last year with a Lion Air subsidiary. Boeing has more than 4,500 orders for the airliners, which feature larger engines, more aerodynamic wings and an upgraded cockpit with larger glass displays. The single-aisle family is Boeing’s biggest source of profit.

Big seller
A Boeing 737 Max jetliner. VietJet has ordered 100 planes to satisfy surging demand. Bloomberg
A Boeing 737 Max jetliner. Bloomberg

Aircraft and engine manufacturers routinely send bulletins to air carriers noting safety measures and maintenance actions they should take, most of them relatively routine. But the urgency of a fatal accident can trigger a flurry of such notices.

After an engine on a Southwest Airlines plane fractured earlier this year over Pennsylvania, killing a passenger, CFM International issued multiple bulletins to operators of its CFM56-7B power plants.

Aviation regulators such as the US FAA and the European Aviation Safety Agency often follow such actions by mandating that carriers follow the bulletins.

Pilots raise and lower the nose of Boeing jetliners by pushing and pulling on a yoke in the cockpit, which controls panels at the tail known as elevators. In addition, a system known as pitch trim can be changed to prompt nose-up or nose-down movement.

The angle of attack readings are fed into a computer that in some cases will attempt to push down the nose using the pitch trim system. In the early days of the jet age, the pitch trim system was linked to several accidents. If pilots aren’t careful, they can cause severe nose-down trim settings that make it impossible to level a plane.

Such an issue arose in 2016 at Rostov-on-Don Airport in Russia when a FlyDubai 737-800 nosed over and slammed into the runway at a steep angle, according to an interim report by Russian investigators. That case didn’t involve the angle-of-attack system. One of the pilots had trimmed the plane to push the nose down while trying to climb after aborting a landing, the report said. All 62 people on board died.

Lion Air's latest crisis illustrates the challenge relatively new carriers face as they try to keep pace with unstoppable demand for air travel in developing nations while striving for standards that mature markets took decades to reach.

Retired air force chief of staff Chappy Hakim, an adviser to the transport ministry, said he avoided flying with Lion Air or other Indonesian airlines, with the exception of Garuda, which has not had a fatal crash since 2007.

"I know Garuda," he said of the national carrier. "The other airlines, I don't believe they do the maintenance and training properly.” He declined to elaborate further.

Lion Air managing director Daniel Putut disputed any laxity in the airline's safety culture, stressing that it conducted maintenance in accordance with manufacturer guidelines.

The Directorate General of Civil Aviation, the Indonesian aviation authority, did not respond to multiple requests for comment about Lion Air’s safety record.

Updated: November 12, 2018 09:07 AM