Text size:

  • Small
  • Normal
  • Large

In response to riot Hollande repeats Sarkozy's mistakes

François Hollande was expected to change Nicholas Sarkozy's right-wing social policies. But his response to riots in Amiens was all too Sarkozy-esque.

There is nothing new about riots in France, but the frequency with which they break out does not make them any easier to manage.

Just ask François Hollande. The newly elected Socialist president anticipated numerous problems during his first few months in office, but a serious urban disturbance was not one of them.

When parts of the northern city of Amiens exploded into violence early this month, Mr Hollande's mind was meant to be on a compassionate social policy to replace years of policy based on ruthless conservatism.

The economics of selfishness and greed, along with repression of troublesome protesters, have caused widespread unrest across France in recent years. Mr Hollande was to be the antidote.

Many of his party colleagues in Amiens certainly viewed discrimination and underinvestment as the roots of the two days of rioting.

Nicolas Sarkozy, Mr Hollande's predecessor, who originally made his name as "Le Top Cop", seemed to view any antisocial behaviour as the work of delinquents.

Mr Sarkozy was an ambitious interior minister when, in the autumn of 2005, scores of cities and towns went up in flames as suburban estates became battlegrounds. A state of emergency was declared for a full three months. Damage totalled €200 (Dh 909mn), with public buildings destroyed, and around 9,000 cars.

It did not seem to matter to Mr Sarkozy that those who lived in those estates were profoundly alienated, with young people in immigrant families complaining that they had next to no opportunities, compared to their counterparts in more affluent areas.

Mr Sarkozy responded the only way he knew how - by sending in hundreds of heavily armed police with orders to be tough. They arrested close to 3,000 people.

His policies created huge antagonism between the forces of law and order and those living on impoverished estates, especially when he described some as "scum" who should be "blown away with a power hose".

This kind of language fit the profile of a man who would become one of France's farthest-right head of states, someone who, in his failed attempt at re-election this May, actively sought the racist, anti-immigrant vote.

Mr Sarkozy is an unreconstructed authoritarian who believes that truncheons and tear gas are as important to maintaining France's social fabric as the deportation of "foreigners who don't fit in".

Many in France expected a left-winger like Mr Hollande to reject this legacy out of hand. Oppressive policies aimed at Muslims, like the burqa ban and moves to ban halal meat, seemed likely to be reversed immediately, and the Socialists were pushing for more resources for oppressed and underfunded communities.

In fact, since the Amiens riot Mr Hollande has had very little to say about revitalising the city. Instead he pledged "zero tolerance", saying more police would be sent into any area that looked vulnerable to disturbances.

There was apparently very little interest in the fact that Fafet, the northern district of Amiens where the worst of the trouble broke out, is racked by unemployment and discrimination. There are numerous economic and social reasons why Fafet is designated a "priority zone", but Mr Hollande seemed oblivious to this fact.

For every mindless troublemaker (and nobody can condone community buildings being burnt down, or buckshot and fireworks being aimed at the police) there are hundreds who feel shut out of mainstream French life by their disadvantaged backgrounds.

Discontent is intensified when successive governments focus on negative perceptions of the kind of immigrant communities found on the estates, and that seems to be just what Mr Hollande is now doing in his turn.

Look at the way France's new Socialist leader has reinvigorated Mr Sarkozy's attacks on gypsy camps. Roma caravans and makeshift huts have this month been destroyed in all major cities.

Many of those made homeless - including hundreds of women and children - have been deported, flown back to Romania or Bulgaria.

Mr Sarkozy infamously equated Roma camps with crime, suggesting that many of the sneak thieves and muggers in France were gypsies. Disease and poor hygiene were also associated with the settlements. The pattern of political attack was always the same - venomous words grouping gypsies with filth, illness and antisocial behaviour.

It is all part of a hateful, discriminatory narrative which Mr Hollande and his pugnacious Interior Minister, Manuel Valls, appear keen to perpetuate. The Socialists are convinced that playing up to calls from right-wing nationalists for a safe, disciplined and "traditional" country will somehow make them more popular.

No matter that Mr Sarkozy was accused of ethnic cleansing in his treatment of the gypsies, or that he regularly stigmatised France's six million Muslims.

Xenophobia is growing in many parts of Europe, as indigenous communities blame newcomers for recession and other unwanted change.

Such a parochial view is anathema to the global, inclusive outlook governments should embrace in this increasingly interconnected, competitive world.

By retreating into the blinkered, oppressive policies which contribute so much to riots in cities like Amiens, Mr Hollande will do absolutely nothing to reverse the years of decline presided over by unthinking reactionaries like Mr Sarkozy.


Nabila Ramdani is a French writer and academic of Algerian origin

On Twitter: @NabilaRamdani

Back to the top

More articles

Editor's Picks

 Thai anti-government protesters blow whistles during a rally at the Metropolitan Electricity Authority in Bangkok, Thailand. Rungroj Yongrit / EPA

Best photography from around the world April 23

The National View's photo editors pick the best of the day from around the world

 Thomas Heatherwick, the designer of Al Fayah park, unveiled his dream of a recreation area that is truly Abu Dhabi at Cityscape 2014 in the capital on April 22, 2014. Fatima Al Marzooqi / The National

Abu Dhabi’s new Al Fayah Park: putting other green space in the shade

Nick Leech speaks to Thomas Heatherwick, the designer of Al Fayah, a park commissioned by the Salama Bint Hamdan Al Nahyan Foundation that hopes to redefine Abu Dhabi's urban landscape.

 Manager Jose Mourinho of Chelsea looks on from the dug out during the Champions League semi-final first leg match against Atletico Madrid on Tuesday. Paul Gilham / Getty Images / April 22, 2014

‘Now the game of our lives is at Stamford Bridge’ says Mourinho after Chelsea, Atletico draw

After Tuesday's scoreless draw, Jose Mourinho revealed Petr Cech's season was over and John Terry was also done unless they could reach the Champions League final.

 Mumbai Indians fans cheer they team on the opening match between Mumbai Indians and Kolkata Knight Riders in IPL 2014 at Zayed Cricket Stadium in Abu Dhabi. Ravindranath K / The National

Earn cash back with the IPL cricket in the UAE

Dunia finance promotion allows cricket lovers to earn up to 6 per cent unlimited cash back on any spending they make on a day when an IPL match is played in the UAE.

 Khalifa Bin Zayed Air College students participate in the 2014 Innovation Challenge. Delores Johnson / The National

In pictures: the UAE Innovation Challenge 2014

The engineering competition brought together almost 100 students from across the country competing in teams to build the best unmanned aircraft.

 Former Manchester United manager David Moyes, right, speaks to Manchester United's Welsh midfielder Ryan Giggs during a training session at the team's Carrington training complex in Manchester, north-west England on April 22, 2014. Andrew Yates / AFP

Giggs a better fit for Manchester United than Moyes

The winger, who has played 962 games for the club, has been placed in interim charge of the first team and will be assisted by his former Manchester United teammate Nicky Butt.


To add your event to The National listings, click here

Get the most from The National