Text size:

  • Small
  • Normal
  • Large

A new manual on mental illness will hurt more than heal

Psychiatry seems to be creating new illnesses rather than eliminating old and existing ones.

Next Wednesday the American Psychiatric Association is set to publish a new edition of its Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM).

This mental diagnostic system is widely used around the world, including in the UAE. But in the run up to the publication of its fifth edition (DSM 5), over 14,000 mental health professionals and more than 50 relevant organisations have signed a petition criticising its content.

The DSM is a tool to help clinicians identify psychiatric illnesses based on checklists of common symptoms. Once an illness has been diagnosed, the clinician proceeds with an appropriate course of treatment. At face value, the system seems reasonable but in reality it raises serious, heavily debated questions about the nature of existence, suffering and illness.

Initial investigations of the DSM focused on how reliable it was in helping to establish diagnoses. For example, if two doctors using the same DSM checklist see the same patient, a high rate of agreement is expected. Also, if a patient receives a diagnosis in May, it is expected that the patient will receive the same diagnosis a few months later. Unfortunately, that is often not the case.

Several studies have shown that the DSM and other diagnostic systems are far from reliable. One study following up a group of patients over two years reported that two fifths of psychiatric diagnoses were changed over the course of the study. People who were initially diagnosed as suffering from, say, bipolar disorder, had their diagnosis changed to schizoaffective disorder or vice versa. Studies have also found rates of diagnostic disagreement between psychiatrists as high as 64 per cent.

Similar concerns have been voiced about the DSM's validity. Where, for example, should we draw the line between illness and normal, common human experiences such as sadness? With reference to depression, many clinicians feel the diagnostic threshold - the line that separates normality from disorder - in the DSM's current edition is already far too low. In DSM 5, it will be even lower. And with reference to validity, what types of behaviours should be regarded as illnesses rather than life-style choices or eccentricities? For instance, internet addiction was discussed for possible inclusion in DSM 5.

One of the confirmed new illnesses appearing in DSM 5 will be known as "disruptive mood dysregulation disorder", which is to be diagnosed in children between the ages of 6 and 12 who tend to be cranky and irritable and exhibit disruptive outbursts more than three times per week. We might once have tried to moderate a child's tantrum by reminding them that a policeman takes naughty boys and girls away. In the future, psychiatrists may come to occupy this behaviour-modifying role.

The British Psychological Society (BPS) has been particularly constructive in its criticism of the DSM. In a 2011 statement to the system's publishers, the BPS expressed concern about the continuous medicalisation of natural and normal responses to distressing experiences. The members also suggested that classifying these problems as illnesses misses the social context, and often the social causes, of such problems.

The US National Institute for Mental Health (NIMH) recently announced that it would no longer be funding psychiatric research that utilised the DSM categories, preferring instead to support research that looks at symptoms that cut across categories. Professor Peter Kinderman, a vocal critic of the DSM 5, described this announcement from NIMH as a "kill shot" to the DSM.

Psychiatry seems to be intent on creating new illnesses rather than eliminating old ones. Professor Richard Bentall, another advocate of reforms to psychiatry, suggests the only ones that benefit from the DSM 5's broader categories and lower diagnostic thresholds are pharmaceutical companies and mental health professionals with busy private practices.

Many psychiatric illnesses are just common human experiences wrapped in a cloak of medical jargon and woven out of sophisticated biochemical theories. This cloak, in some cases, might be comforting, but it also masks the true nature of the problem and offers only drugs to numb the pain.

Within the context of the UAE, we should be particularly wary of the DSM 5, as this latest edition of "psychiatry's Bible" is likely to medicalise a lot of normal, culturally-appropriate responses to distress.


Justin Thomas is an assistant professor of psychology at Zayed University

On Twitter: @jaytee156

Back to the top

More articles

Editor's Picks

 An Egyptian Orthodox Christian priest give communion during the Palm Sunday service inCairo, Egypt. Mohamed El-Shahed / AFP

Region in focus - April 18, 2014

The best images of the last seven days from around the Gulf and across the Middle East.

 Above, the private pool of Ocean Heights' five-bedroom penthouse flat. Courtesy Christie’s International Real Estate

In pictures: Penthouse flat is height of Dubai luxury living

A five-bedroom penthouse in Ocean Heights in Dubai Marina is on sale for Dh25 million and comes with a private pool and an unparalleled view of Dubai.

Video: Local reactions to a national fishing ban

A federal fishing ban has been imposed by the UAE federal government, but local authorities are taking diiferent approaches to implementing the ban. Two fishermen tell two very different sides of the story. Produced by Paul O'Driscoll

 Southampton owner Katharina Liebherr is pictured before the Premier League match between Southampton and Liverpool at St Mary's Stadium in Southampton, southern England, on March 1, 2014. Glyn Kirk / AFP

New Southampton owner leading club’s resurgence from the shadows

Katharina Liebherr keeping with family tradition and letting others dominate the spotlight

 The new Bentley GT Speed convertible on display at a press event of the New York International Auto Show. Jason Szenes / EPA

In pictures: Hot cars at New York International Auto Show

With more than 1 million visitors annually, the New York International Auto Show is one of the most important shows for the US car industry. Here are some of the vehicles to be shown in this year’s edition.

 The cast of Fast & Furious 7, including Michelle Rodriguez and Vin Diesel, centre, on set at Emirates Palace in Abu Dhabi. Jeffrey E Biteng / The National

Fast & Furious 7 filming in full swing at Emirates Palace

Filming for Fast & Furious 7 has started and we have the first photos of the cast and crew on set at Emirates Palace hotel this morning. Visitors staying at Emirates Palace say they have been kept away from certain areas in the grounds.


To add your event to The National listings, click here

Get the most from The National