Text size:

  • Small
  • Normal
  • Large
New Sunderland head coach Paolo Di Canio during his time as Swindon Town manager.
New Sunderland head coach Paolo Di Canio during his time as Swindon Town manager.

Sunderland's shock tactics in taking risk on Paolo di Canio

Sunderland cannot afford to be relegated this season, warns Jonathan Wilson - which may explain the club's risky decision to replace Martin O'Neill with the controversial Italian.

In Niall Quinn's brief stint as Sunderland manager in 2006, he said that the club was blighted by "gremlins", the ghosts of failures past and the culture of underachievement. When he appointed Roy Keane as his own successor, at least part of the logic was to scare those gremlins away.

Briefly it worked: promotion was gained and, although Sunderland have been through three managers since Keane, they are one season off their longest stint in the top flight since first being relegated in 1958.

The problem is that the gremlins have returned. Having decided Martin O'Neill wasn't the man to shoo them away, Sunderland's owner Ellis Short turned to the scariest available option: Paolo di Canio.

This is an almighty gamble. Two weeks ago, Sunderland announced an annual loss of 27m. With a new TV deal kicking in at the end of this year, relegation would effectively deny them between 40m and 50m in broadcasting revenue alone; they simply cannot afford to go down.

That is why O'Neill, who admitted a lack of "real true ability" in the squad despite spending 22m on Stephen Fletcher and Adam Johnson last summer, went; less clear is why Di Canio has been appointed. His record at Swindon was impressive but his time there before flouncing out was so fraught his chief executive described his style as "management by hand grenade". The theory is presumably that players need to be shocked into life.

And then there is the matter of Di Canio's political beliefs. The widespread belief in Britain is that he positions himself on the far right but the situation seems rather less clear than that and the resignation of the former foreign secretary David Miliband as Sunderland's vice-chairman over the issue - seemingly without having consulted the Italian - is just another piece of expediency from a man at the forefront of a political class that has always valued image over substance. He had already announced he is retiring as an MP to move to New York.

Still, it would be useful if Di Canio clarified what he meant when, in 2005, he pronounced himself "a fascist not a racist". The journalist Gabriele Marcotti, who ghosted Di Canio's autobiography, has pointed out that the often-cited sentence from that book in which Di Canio describes Benito Mussolini s "misunderstood" is part of a passage condemning him.

Marcotti is cautious but suggests what Di Canio warmed to in Italian fascism was its pre-1933 guise when it meant "order, security, unions, national pride, universal pensions, government mortgages".

Whatever the truth of Di Canio's views, Miliband's actions show the awkward situation in which Sunderland now find themselves. They are perceived to have a fascist as a manager and that can only have a negative impact on a public image that is far from robust to start with.

Sunderland seem to have spent most of the past decade shunning publicity - refusing, for instance, to allow Asamoah Gyan to be interview by France Football when he was longlisted for the Ballon d'or - and with little positive image to sustain them, they may find the vacuum filled by negativity.

What matters most to the majority of fans - and to Short - though is whether Sunderland stay up. An away game at Chelsea isn't the ideal place to start but a derby away to Newcastle United the following week offers Di Canio the chance for instant glory.

No side that has sacked its manager in March in the Premier League has ever previous survived but the thinking seems to have been than anything was better than the slow sink into the Championship that seemed to be going on.


twitter Follow us @SprtNationalUAE and Jonathan Wilson @jonawils

Back to the top

More articles

Editor's Picks

 Manager Matt Williams benching star Bryce Harper, above, may have sent the wrong message to the rest of the Washington Nationals. Mike Ehrmann / AFP

Benching Harper sends Williams’s right message the wrong way

Matt Williams, the Washington Nationals manager, made the biggest move of his 18-game tenure on Saturday, benching rising star Bryce Harper for his “lack of hustle”.

 Players such as George Springer are a sign that things are starting to swing in the Houston Astros' favour. But more help is needed. Scott Halleran / AFP

Houston Astros are still earth-bound but help is on the way

As harbingers of a new era go, the Houston Astros could have done worse than misspelling their new phenom’s name on his major-league debut.

 Luis Suarez became the first Liverpool player to score 30 Premier League goals in a season since Ian Rush in 1987. Stefan Wermuth / Reuters

Sterling and Suarez inpire Liverpool to win over Norwich City

The win takes the Premier League table-toppers to 80 points from 35 games.

 Arsenal's Lukas Podolski celebrates his second goal during the Premier League match against Hull City at The KC Stadium in Hull, England, on April 20, 2014. Lynne Cameron / AP Photo

Arsenal maintain push for top-four finish with victory at Hull

Hull could end up in Europe regardless of the FA Cup final result if Arsenal finish in the Uefa Champions League places

 Chelsea’s manager Jose Mourinho, second from right, holds back assistant coach Rui Faria, centre, after he was sent off by referee Mike Dean, left, during their Premier League match against Sunderland at Stamford Bridge in London. Philip Brown / Reuters

Angry Jose Mourinho mocks referees for ‘fantastic performance’ after Chelsea defeat

Manager targets Mike Dean, who awarded the 82nd-minute penalty from which Fabio Borini scored the winning goal for Sunderland.

 Michelle Wie’s other two LPGA titles also came in North America, at the 2009 Lorena Ochoa Invitational in Mexico and at Canadian Women’s Open in August of 2010. Jamie Squire / Getty Images

Michelle Wie’s win snaps LPGA title drought

The American, who erased a four-shot deficit to win with a 14-under par total of 274, wins her third career LPGA crown.


To add your event to The National listings, click here

Get the most from The National