Text size:

  • Small
  • Normal
  • Large
Michael Carrick, left, Robin van Persie, centre, and Patrice Evra are the only players to have started more than three-quarters of Manchester United's Premier League matches so far this season. Peter Powell / EPA
Michael Carrick, left, Robin van Persie, centre, and Patrice Evra are the only players to have started more than three-quarters of Manchester United's Premier League matches so far this season. Peter Powell / EPA

Selections of Manchester United's Sir Alex Ferguson hard to predict

The veteran manager has the element of surprise tomorrow and his mix-and-match teams are a reason why Manchester United have been successful this season, writes Richard Jolly.

There is a game Sir Bobby Charlton likes to play which he never wins. Manchester United's record goalscorer and director tries to guess Sir Alex Ferguson's next team selection. Getting all 11 names right, however, is beyond even an Old Trafford insider.

So what chance, then, does a rival manager, even a master psychologist like Jose Mourinho, have?

When Real Madrid arrive at Old Trafford tomorrow, they may have a United team in mind. The reality, though, is that nine names will be accompanied by two question marks, an uncertainty that affects both formation and style.

In the midfield and forward positions, they can suppose Michael Carrick, Danny Welbeck, Wayne Rooney and Robin van Persie will start.

With Phil Jones ruled out with an ankle injury, Ferguson will be perming two from Tom Cleverley, Anderson, Ryan Giggs, Ashley Young, Antonio Valencia, Shinji Kagawa and Nani.

The consequence is that Rooney could be on either flank or just behind Van Persie. Ferguson may have two or three genuine central midfielders.

Practically the only guarantee is that the resident super-sub, Javier Hernandez, will be held in reserve.

While some become more set in their ways with age, Ferguson grows more unpredictable, preserving the element of surprise.

He can set his side up to counter opponents, as he has done against Chelsea, Manchester City and Liverpool in the Premier League.

Other managers find it harder to do likewise. Second-guessing Ferguson is no simple task.

The side that beat Norwich City 4-0 on Saturday was stronger than expected: few anticipated Rooney, Van Persie and Carrick all starting while Ferguson, typically, threw a curveball by saying Giggs, who was not even on the bench, would feature.

Picking and choosing the games for his veterans, the 39-year-old Giggs and the 38-year-old Paul Scholes, is one reason why managing United has become a job for a strategist.

So are the circumstances. Ferguson does not have the array of genuine superstars that the top Spanish sides - or, arguably, the finest German teams - now possess. United's finances have not permitted it. Between the 80 million (Dh441.6m) sale of Cristiano Ronaldo in 2009 and the arrivals of Van Persie and, to a lesser extent, Kagawa, last summer, they were not signing players at their height of their powers or with a commensurate cost.

The criticism was that they ended up with quantity, not quality. Yet Ferguson has strength in depth and the ability, which many of his managerial counterparts lack, to ensure everyone contributes.

Nani had been perhaps United's most disappointing player this season but he was responsible for progress against Reading in the FA Cup; Kagawa, until then struggling for goals, delivered a hat-trick against Norwich; Young, otherwise underwhelming, was excellent in the most significant league game of the campaign, the 3-2 win at Manchester City.

They exist in a world of permanent rotation. Even in the centre of defence, a department most managers leave untouched, Ferguson tinkers, partly because of the creaking frames of his veterans.

Nemanja Vidic is the most resolute choice for domestic matches.

Jonny Evans and Rio Ferdinand, more mobile and less likely to concede free kicks, should get the nod tomorrow.

It all explains why only Carrick, Van Persie and Patrice Evra have started more than three-quarters of the league games, and why, when United are confirmed as champions, this will have been a genuine triumph of the entire group.

Ferguson believes his squad is deeper than his pool of players in 1999 and that, the treble-winning campaign, was notable for decisive, dramatic contributions Teddy Sheringham and Ole Gunnar Solskjaer made from the bench in the Champions League final.

The corollary is that the squad is stronger but the first-choice side weaker. The difference is most pronounced in the centre of the park.

Any opponent in a major match 14 years ago could have predicted the presence, if fit, of Roy Keane, David Beckham and Giggs, accompanied by either Scholes or Nicky Butt. Each was aged between 24 and 28, players at their physical peak whose athleticism was married with technical ability and a fierce competitiveness.

Instead of the masters, Ferguson now has mix-and-match midfields, where only Carrick is an automatic choice, where there could be four men or five, where a diamond system is occasionally deployed, where most of the many options are flexible enough to occupy two or three roles.

When a defender like Jones plays in midfield to help halt Gareth Bale or Marouane Fellaini, it can indicate an inferiority complex.

If the out-of-form Valencia, the best defensive right winger, is included to help Rafael deal with Ronaldo, or Rooney is again sacrificed to track his former partner in crime, it will suggest that United are more worried about Madrid than vice versa.

Truth be told, Ferguson's tactics have long entailed the tacit acceptance that United cannot simply send a side out to blow their rivals away.

Instead, it becomes a question of cunning, of bluff and double bluff, of deciding which cards to play. Manchester United against Real Madrid is football at its finest. For Ferguson, looking to outwit Mourinho, it is also a game of poker.


twitter Follow us @SprtNationalUAE

More articles

Editor's Picks

 F1 driver Sebastian Vettel of Red Bull Racing is fifth in the Formula One drivers' standings, 46 points behind leader Nico Rosberg. Diego Azubel / EPA / April 20, 2014

Nothing Vettel can do about car, but Ricciardo’s superiority should be worrying

It isn't Sebastian Vettel's fault his Renault-powered Red Bull Racing car is so inferior to the Mercedes, writes Graham Caygill, but he isn't proving much by being outpaced by teammate Daniel Ricciardo.

 Paul Pierce and the Nets own a 1-0 lead in the best-of-seven series against Toronto. Warren Toda / EPA

‘Dinosaur’ Brooklyn Nets roaming ominously in NBA play-offs

Brooklyn's veterans found their form toward the end of the season and now pose a threat in the East, writes Jonathan Raymond.

 The Eastern Conference play-offs have provided the bigger shocks so far, such as Jeff Teague, left, and the Atlanta Hawks win over the Indiana Pacers. Steve C Mitchell / EPA

In the NBA play-offs, better play finally rises in East

It took six months and 82 games but, finally, the Eastern Conference has become interesting.

 Stanislas Wawrinka lifts the Monte Carlo Masters trophy after his triumph over Roger Federer on Sunday. Claude Paris / AP / April 20, 2014

Wawrinka on the rise after topping Federer for Monte Carlo Masters title

The Australian Open champion suggested he is not just a one-major wonder as he bounced back to beat Federer in the Monte Carlo Masters final on Sunday for his first Masters title.

 Roger Federer seemed to wear down during his Monte Carlo Masters loss to Stanislas Wawrinka in the final on April 20, 2014. Wawrinka won 4-6, 7-6, 6-2. Michael Euler / AP Photo

Roger Federer sees positives but one negative remains

There is plenty to cheer about for Roger Federer fans, but there could be one worrying indication.

 Diego Simeone has used Atletico Madrid supporters to his player’ advantage.

Neutrals’ favourites Atletico Madrid start as underdogs against Chelsea

It has been 18 seasons since they won the Primera Liga title but 40 years since reaching the Champions League final, but they dare to dream, writes Ian Hawkey.


To add your event to The National listings, click here

Get the most from The National