Text size:

  • Small
  • Normal
  • Large
The problem is the newcomers have big boots to fill once Tendulkar and Dravid exit the scene.
The problem is the newcomers have big boots to fill once Tendulkar and Dravid exit the scene.

Time for India's selectors to bite the bullet like Packers did on Favre

With no tough overseas assignments for two years after Australia's tour, there's no better time for transition for Indian cricket.

Just how do you follow in the footsteps of a legend? You can't, or you don't. The only way is to chart your own course, as Aaron Rodgers and the Green Bay Packers have proved over the last four National Football League seasons.

The time has come for Indian cricket to take some huge decisions, to say goodbye to a golden age and to usher in a new one whose early days are likely to be difficult.

It is not a call that can be delayed. After six emphatic defeats in successive overseas Tests, the writing could not be any clearer on the wall.

There are some who say things would have been even worse but for the efforts of Sachin Tendulkar, Rahul Dravid and VVS Laxman. But what could be worse than three innings defeats, and three by a combined margin of 637 runs?

Virat Kohli has 43 runs from four innings in Australia. But dropping him would not make a lot of sense. At 23, he is one of the future. So is Rohit Sharma, who now has an excellent chance of playing in Perth.

Laxman, the youngest of the famed trio, is 37. Dravid, the oldest, turns 39 two days before the third Test.

By investing in them, Indian cricket will once again be guilty of choosing the short-term fix over a long-term succession plan.

The Packers bit the bullet in 2008. By then, Brett Favre, a quarterback so tough he made 297 consecutive starts, had spent 16 seasons at Lambeau Field, winning the Super Bowl once.

Only three times in those 16 years did the Packers not win at least nine [of 16] regular season games.

In his final year, Favre led them to a 13-3 record, losing the National Football Conference Championship game to the New York Giants in overtime.

A couple of months later, at a press conference, he said: "I know I can play, but I don't think I want to. It's been a great career for me, but it's over. As they say, all good things must come to an end."

Within months, he had a change of heart, but with some in the Packers organisation having made their plans for the future, it only led to a messy and acrimonious divorce.

Favre would go on to play a season for the New York Jets and two for the Minnesota Vikings, but his name will forever be linked with Green Bay.

Rodgers was 24 when he assumed the mantle. In his first season, the Packers finished 6-10.

Since then, they have gone 11-5, 10-6 and 15-1, winning a Super Bowl along the way. They remain favourites to repeat the feat next month.

Rodgers himself has the highest passer rating of any quarterback with at least 1,500 passing attempts. The unproven talent who replaced a legend is well on the way to becoming one himself.

India's batting stalwarts are still good enough to command a place in the side.

Dravid scored three centuries on the forgettable tour of England. Tendulkar has looked in sparkling form despite the relative lack of runs, and Laxman scored a big hundred in Kolkata just three Tests ago.

But with no tough overseas assignments for two years after this tour, there's no better time for transition.

Dilip Vengsarkar, who played his final Test in Perth 20 years ago - the same game in which an 18-year-old Tendulkar made one of his most famous hundreds - told Cricinfo: "The bitter truth is that we don't have new champion players who can take up the mantle. We might have left the best behind.

"We've been spoilt by success in the past 10-12 years. The big batting guns have long covered up other shortcomings but they are nearing the end. The increased dependence on Tendulkar after more than two decades is a sign of poverty."

Better times await, but only if India have the courage to break with the past and embrace the future.


Back to the top

More articles

Editor's Picks

 Floyd Mayweather lands punches on trainer Nate Jones on Tuesday at the Mayweather Boxing Club in Las Vegas ahead of his May 3 championship unification bout with Marcos Maidana. Ethan Miller / Getty Images / AFP / April 22, 2014

In pictures: Floyd Mayweather trains for Maidana fight

Images from earlier in the week as Floyd Mayweather trained at the Mayweather Boxing Club in Las Vegas ahead of his May 3 championship unification fight with Marcos Maidana.

 UAE rugby player Daniel Minks pushes against a Singapore tackler during Wednesday night’s Asian Five Nations Test. Sarah Dea / The National / April 23, 2014

UAE national rugby team needs to look within to raise standards

While domestic clubs like Jebel Ali Dragons and Abu Dhabi Harlequins find regional success, the UAE national side isn't benefitting from the talent pool in the country, writes Paul Radley.

 Ravindra Jadeja of Chennai Super Kings playing a shot in their Indian Premier League win over Rajasthan Royals at Dubai International Cricket Stadium on Wednesday. Jadeja scored 36 runs not out from 33 balls. Pawan Singh / The National / April 23, 2014

In pictures: Chennai Super Kings notch win behind do-everything Jadeja

Images from Wednesday night's Indian Premier League match in Dubai, where Ravindra Jadeja led Chennai Super Kings over Rajasthan Royals.

 Suresh Raina has scored 84 runs in three IPL matches so far this season for Chennai Super Kings. Ravindranatah K / The National

Suresh Raina has always been brightest in Chennai yellow

An enigmatic presence in India's line-up, writes Osman Samiuddin, Suresh Raina is at his freest, his easiest and his best with the IPL's Chennai Super Kings.

 Azzam crew member Luke Parkinson works on the new 65-foot carbon racing yacht during preparation for the Volvo Ocean Race. Courtesy Ian Roman / ADOR

A little calm after the storm for Azzam crew

Azzam skipper Ian Walker writes another monthly update ahead of the Volvo Ocean Race as his crew enjoy a 10-day break after some rough conditions following their delivery from the UK to Portugal.

 Singapore have nearly half the side in home-grown players and prefer not to be reliant on expatriates. Sarah Dea / The National / April 23, 2014

Asian Five Nations: Singapore ideal model for impatient UAE’s rugby federation

The UAE Rugby Federation are keen for their national team to have such heavy Emirati representation. They have a good template to follow.


To add your event to The National listings, click here

Get the most from The National