Text size:

  • Small
  • Normal
  • Large

When the truth is a casualty, many more will also suffer

Two recent news stories that have disgraced the industry and made innocent people suffer: the case of stolen identities in the Mossad-led hit on a Hamas operative, and a case of mistaken identity for Iran's "Neda".

I am not easily shocked. I've been doing this work for too many years and I've seen too much to become outraged by bad behaviour or acts of indecency and inhumanity. But two stories that recently came across my desk were so disgraceful, and in some ways dangerous, that I feel compelled to write about them. Both featured players in the Middle East who are crassly abusing the living and the dead. The first story involved Israel's Mossad spy agency and the method it allegedly used to secure a fraudulent passport for one of its agents who participated in the January 19, 2010 assassination of Mahmoud al Mabhouh in Dubai.

German law offers citizenship and a passport to the descendants of German Jewish citizens who were forced to flee the country to escape the horrors of the Holocaust during the Second World War. Taking advantage of this provision, a Mossad agent claiming to be Michael Bodenheimer, the grandson of a German Jewish survivor, secured a German passport which he later used to enter the UAE, where he was allegedly involved in the murder of al Mabhouh.

A few weeks ago, the Jerusalem Post reported that the real Michael Bodenheimer, an Orthodox rabbi who emigrated from the United States to Israel, claimed that his identity had been stolen by the Mossad agent, and that he had "never asked for a German passport... [and] never had one". The real Mr Bodenheimer and his family were, of course, concerned that their name was implicated in an assassination.

More than just this abuse of one innocent civilian, there is a real concern about the Mossad's cavalier abuse of the German citizenship programme. Israel's behaviour in this regard is dangerous. It puts the real Mr Bodenheimer at risk while casting suspicion on an entire category of people - Jews who have sought, or will seek, German citizenship. As such, the agency callously exploited those who were murdered and the descendants of those who survived.

Then there are the recent revelations about the Iranian woman who was murdered in the demonstrations that erupted after last year's Iranian elections. The woman, Neda Agha-Soltan, quickly became internationally recognised as a martyr and a symbol of the "Green revolution". Her face was consistently shown on CNN and BBC television news, and plastered on the front pages of newspapers around the world, where it often appeared with the tagline "the Angel of Iran". One particular photo was picked up by the Voice of America and spread to Iran, where it appears on posters and T-shirts.

The story is true: Neda Agha-Soltan was murdered. But the picture that spread virally is not of her. Careless journalism, to be kind, picked up the Facebook photo of one Neda Soltani, a quite beautiful Iranian teaching assistant and student of English Literature at Tehran University. Despite the mistaken identity, the photo stuck. A piece on Foreign Policy's website last week carefully traces not just the carelessness that lead to the mistaken identity but, more disturbingly, the consequences for the living Ms Soltani who is the innocent victim of this error.

As she sought to reclaim her identity and her image, the Iranian regime sought to exploit her situation, claiming that "Neda lives", vainly arguing that the entire episode was a hoax and that no murder had been committed. When Ms Soltani went online demanding that her picture be taken down, she received threats and abusive responses from supporters of the movement who argued that she was threatening to deny their cause the martyred "Angel of Iran".

And when the parents of the murdered woman attempted to replace the mistaken photo with one of their daughter, they found that neither their efforts nor the truth could compete with the symbol. Fearing pressure from the regime, and frustrated by the loss of her identity, the living Ms Soltani was forced to flee Iran and take refuge in Germany where she currently lives. As disturbing as these stories are, equally troubling is the lack of attention they have received, particularly in the United States. With the exception of the Foreign Policy piece, the story of Ms Soltani has received scant attention when compared with the coverage given to the use of the original photo last summer - while the Bodenheimer story has not been covered at all.

The lesson that emerges from all of this is that when governments, media and movements abuse the living and dead to pursue their ends, truth and innocent people pay the price. James Zogby is the president of the Arab American Institute

Back to the top

More articles

Editor's Picks

 Iranian President Hassan Rouhani greets supporters after his arrival in Zahedan, the regional capital of Sistan and Baluchestan province on Tuesday, April 15, 2014. During Mr Rouhani's two-day visit, he will tour several other cities and hold meetings with local scholars and entrepreneurs. Maryam Rahmanian for The National

On the road with Hassan Rouhani

Iran's president is touring some of Iran's most underdeveloped provinces. Foreign correspondent Yeganeh Salehi is traveling with him.

 The Doha-based Youssef Al Qaradawi speaks to the crowd as he leads Friday prayers in Tahrir Square in Cairo, Egypt in February, 2011. The outspoken pro-Muslim Brotherhood imam has been critical of the UAE’s policies toward Islamist groups, adding to friction between Qatar and other GCC states. Khalil Hamra / AP Photo

Brotherhood imam skips Doha sermon, but more needed for GCC to reconcile

That Youssef Al Qaradawi did not speak raises hopes that the spat involving Qatar and the UAE, Saudi Arabia and Bahrain might be slowly moving towards a resolution.

 Twitter photo of  Abdel Fattah El Sisi on the campaign trail on March 30. Photo courtesy-Twitter/@SisiCampaign

El Sisi rides a bicycle, kicks off social media storm

The photos and video created a huge buzz across social media networks, possibly a marker of a new era for Egypt.

 An Afghan election commission worker carries a ballot box at a vote counting centre in Jalalabad on April 6. A roadside bomb hit a truck carrying full ballot boxes in northern Afghanistan, killing three people a day after the country voted for a successor to President Hamid Karzai. Eight boxes of votes were destroyed in the blast, which came as the three leading candidates voiced concerns about possible fraud. Noorullah Shirzada / AFP Photo

Two pressing questions for Afghanistan’s future president

Once in office, the next Afghan president must move fast to address important questions that will decide the immediate future of the country.

 Friday is UN Mine Awareness Day and Omer Hassan, who does demining work in Iraqi Kurdistan, is doing all he can to teach people about the dangers posed by landmines. Louise Redvers for The National

A landmine nearly ended Omer’s life but he now works to end the threat of mines in Iraq

Omer Hassan does demining work in Iraqi Kurdistan and only has to show people his mangled leg to underscore the danger of mines. With the world marking UN Mine Awareness Day on Friday, his work is as important as ever as Iraq is one of the most mine-affected countries in the world.

 Supporters of Turkey's ruling AKP cheer as they follow the election's results in front of the party's headquarters in Ankara on March 30. Adem Altan/ AFP Photo

Erdogan critic fears retaliation if he returns to Turkey

Emre Uslu is a staunch critic of Turkey's Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan. Now, with a mass crackdown on opposition expected, he is unsure when he can return home.


To add your event to The National listings, click here

Get the most from The National