Text size:

  • Small
  • Normal
  • Large

Murder trials must follow Sharia law, Supreme Court rules

Judges in capital murder cases must follow Sharia law without exception, the Federal Supreme Court says, threatening long delays in some trials.

ABU DHABI // Judges in capital murder cases must follow Sharia law without exception, the Federal Supreme Court has ruled - but experts say the decision could mean long delays in some trials. The requirements of Sharia state that the victim's relatives must accept or decline blood money in court. But in cases in which the victim's relatives cannot be easily found or cannot attend court, trials can be adjourned for months or even years.

In extreme instances, where there are no relatives, the judge, acting in the name of the state, will become the victim's guardian and decide on blood money. The UAE legal system follows a dual track, with laws passed by the Government and Sharia law functioning side-by-side. Judges have discretion as to which laws take precedence. The Supreme Court ruling, handed down on June 8 and publicly disclosed in a document released this week, says judges have no discretion in cases of premeditated murder, which call for the death penalty.

The case in the ruling originated in Sharjah and involved an illegal immigrant whose identity was never known. SSS, an Indian, was convicted of murder late last year by Sharjah Criminal Court and sentenced to death. But the court of appeal changed the sentence to life imprisonment. Neither court followed the Sharia requirement for the family of the victim to attend the sentencing. Prosecutors appealed to the Federal Supreme Court, which ruled that only Sharia law applies in such cases, meaning the family's blood money decision must be included before the case could continue.

"Cases that involve premeditated murder must be tried according to Sharia law if the case met the Islamic conditions," Chief Justice Falah al Hajeri wrote in the court document. "It has been proved that he intentionally killed the victim, which means the case must be tried according to Sharia." At least two such cases in Abu Dhabi Criminal Court are in indefinite adjournment because of the ruling.

In one, AK, 39, a driver, was convicted of killing ZRR, his employer's cook, after she told him she was pregnant. He first appeared before the Criminal Court three months ago and his case has been repeatedly adjourned because the family of the victim, who is from Indonesia, has not been able to attend to say whether they wanted blood money. Justice Ahmed Abdulhameed of the Federal Supreme Court, who specialises in murder cases, said the Supreme Court ruling ensured that the victim's family's rights were upheld.

"There is only one way to prevent a death penalty: when the family of the victim forfeit their right either by accepting the blood money or forgiving the victim," Justice Abdulhameed said in an interview. "This is a right guaranteed by the Islamic Sharia to the family of the victim; no one can deprive them that right unless they say yes or no to the death penalty." He said public prosecutors must exert maximum effort in finding relatives.

"It does not mean that when we implement the Sharia law, the defendant is guaranteed a death sentence," he said. "On the contrary, the family in most cases forfeit their right and would accept the blood money." If the family does not accept the blood money, he said, negotiations would continue until the moment of execution, at which the family must be present. He said the Government usually encourages families to accept the blood money, and in some cases the Government itself pays.

Salim Muntaser, a legal consultant based in Abu Dhabi, said the court has the power to force victims' relatives to attend the trial, but rarely used it. He cited a case, currently at the Court of Cassation, that has been in progress for a year and two months because the family of the victim did not wish to attend. The victim, an Emirati from Al Ain, was killed in his house by a man from Sri Lanka who was having an affair with the victim's housemaid. The Sri Lankan was sentenced to death more than a year ago, but the Emirati man's family refused to attend the appeal trials in protest.

"If they refuse to attend, the court can order the police to arrest them," Mr Muntaser said. "But usually they do not do that out of respect for their feelings." hhassan@thenational.ae

Back to the top

More articles


Editor's Picks

 Shah Rukh Khan performs at the IPL Gala dinner to open IPL VII at the Emirates Palace hotel in Abu Dhabi.

In pictures: Shah Rukh Khan stars at IPL Gala dinner in Abu Dhabi

The superstar entertainer Shah Rukh Khan on stage last night at a gala dinner to launch the Indian Premier League cricket tournament.

No words can describe this April 17, your captions will

Have a catchy caption for this picture. Share it with us and we might publish it and reward you.

 The year-long project aims to create a form of social autobiography — the story of Dubai documented by those who know it best, the people who live there.

Zoom in! This is your Dubai in a single image

On our sixth birthday, we are all about pictures. So here is our #mydubai offering. Using zoom.it, explore the city.

 This Dh17,000 Miele system can prepare your choice of coffee - from capuccino to espresso - at a touch of a button. Pawan Singh / The National

In pictures: Miele puts art in coffee making

Miele has devoted itself to the art of preparing the black liquid with its beautifully designed coffee machines, living up to its mantra of turning kitchens into cafés.

 Iranian President Hassan Rouhani greets supporters after his arrival in Zahedan, the regional capital of Sistan and Baluchestan province on Tuesday, April 15, 2014. During Mr Rouhani's two-day visit, he will tour several other cities and hold meetings with local scholars and entrepreneurs. Maryam Rahmanian for The National

On the road with Hassan Rouhani

Iran's president is touring some of Iran's most underdeveloped provinces. Foreign correspondent Yeganeh Salehi is traveling with him.

 Amir Khan, during a workout at the Gloves Community Centre on March 24, 2014 in Bolton, England, says his fight will be the real main event in Las Vegas on May 3. Alex Livesey/Getty Images

Amir Khan says bout with Luis Collazo ‘will steal the show’ in Las Vegas on May 3

British-Pakistani boxer Amir Khan says his fight with Luis Collazo will be the main attraction on same fight card led by Floyd Mayweather Jr and Marcos Maidana, writes Omar Al Raisi.

Events

To add your event to The National listings, click here

Get the most from The National