Text size:

  • Small
  • Normal
  • Large
the Abu Dhabi Securities Exchange General Index has declined by 60 per cent since 2005. Galen Clarke / The National
the Abu Dhabi Securities Exchange General Index has declined by 60 per cent since 2005. Galen Clarke / The National

Soured stock deals spawn rash of disputes

Tumbling stock markets have stoked a spate of legal clashes between brokers and their clients on disputed trades made at the peak of the market.

Declining stock markets have produced a spate of legal clashes between brokers and their clients over trades made at the peak of the market.

Brokerages are required to settle all commercial disputes before they can be dissolved, and as the number of firms looking to wind up has increased, so too have arguments between trading houses and disaffected clients.

"In the last three years, court cases related to stock market disputes have not just doubled, or tripled, they have quadrupled," said Mohammed Ali Yasin, the chief investment officer at CAPM Investment in Abu Dhabi.

Brokers who had verbal agreements to trade on their clients' behalf before the 2008 plunge have tried to dodge responsibility on the loss of clients' wealth. On the other side, investors who leveraged their positions through so-called margin trading have tried to avoid paying for soured investments, alleging that brokers had no written agreements to trade on their behalf.

"There has been a huge increase in disputes raised at the courts as a result of irregularities made by brokerages during the global financial crisis," said Mahmoud Homidat, an associate at the law firm Al Tamimi & Company. "The frequent cases are related to brokerages, who took out loans from banks and extended them to clients as unregulated facilities, [and] are now asking clients to pay outstanding dues after markets slumped and trading volumes crashed."

Mr Homidat said that last year he personally handled three such cases worth between Dh27 million (US$7.3m) and Dh100m.

Globally, brokerages record telephone conversations to limit the potential for disputed buy and sell orders. But this was often overlooked in the Emirates between 2005 and 2008, when traders often accepted orders from intermediaries acting for clients, through fear of losing their future business.

"Global best practices were secondary and even tertiary at times to a lot of clients and the brokerage houses during the boom times," said an in-house lawyer for one of the UAE's largest brokerages. "The markets were seeing a big influx of money coming from the West and the East and not thinking what should happen when things collapse such as taking orders on a non-recorded line and extending unreasonable financing facilities."

The Dubai Financial Market General Index has dropped by 80 per cent since its peak in 2005, while the Abu Dhabi Securities Exchange General Index has declined by 60 per cent in the same period.

Brokerages complain that they are sometimes disadvantaged by the parallel dispute resolution avenues open to claimants.

"Clients will go to SCA [Securities and Commodities Authority] to address a complaint If the decision comes in favour of the client the brokerage is penalised. But if the decision is made in favour of the brokerage, clients will more than often disregard the ruling and refer directly to the courts," Mr Yasin said.

He would like to see the SCA attend hearings related to trade disputes at Abu Dhabi and Dubai's Judicial Department as technical experts to replace the current committee, which includes a handful of auditors and accountants, who he says have limited experience in stock market-related disputes.

"The legal framework in the judicial system needs to be more robust," Mr Yasin said. "The current system is bringing brokerages large liabilities."

There are 61 brokerage companies in the UAE, down from 105 last year as markets slumped and trading volumes crashed.

"About 80 per cent of the operating financial firms have outstanding cases with their clients," said Ashraf Taha Amin, a partner at Al Noor Auditing Bureau and a mediator at Abu Dhabi's Judicial Department.

halsayegh@thenational.ae

Back to the top

More articles


Editor's Picks

 The Greens, villas: Q1 no change. 3BR - Dh210-250,000. 4BR - Dh210-260,000. 5BR - Dh220-300,000. Q1 2013-Q1 2014 5% rise. Pawan Singh / The National

In pictures: Where Dubai rents have risen and fallen, Q1 2014

Find out how rental prices in the prime locations in Dubai have altered during the first three months of the year and the current rates you will pay according to data provided by Asteco.

 Miele coffee maker making Cappuccino at Miele Gallery in Sama Tower in Dubai. The cost of this coffee maker is around Dh 17,000. Pawan Singh / The National

Space-age coffee comes at a price from Miele

Miele have taken the coffee machine to a new level with its Dh17,000 offering that is built into your kitchen.

 The bridge of Seajacks Hydra, as the wind farm installation vessel undergoes finishing touches and testing works at Lamprell’s Hamriyah facility in Sharjah before its planned delivery on June 2, 2014. Jeffrey E Biteng / The National

In pictures: Building the Seajacks Hydra

The Seajacks Hydra, a wind farm installation vessel, is undergoing finishing touches and testing works at Lamprell’s Hamriyah facility in Sharjah before its planned delivery on June 2, 2014.

 The Wind, Energy, Technology and Environment Exhibition takes place from April 14 to April 16. Above, the Dewa showroom during last year’s Wetex. Jaime Puebla / The National

April corporate and economic calendar for the UAE and overseas

From Cityscape to Wetex to stock-market holidays to nations reporting first-quarter GDP figures, here is our helpful calendar of April's business events in the UAE and internationally.

 The rush of new supply of hotel rooms pushed Dubai occupancy rates down to 87 per cent. Sarah Dea / The National

Dubai hotel room rates rise 10 per cent

The rush of new supply pushed occupancy rates down to 87 per cent, a dip of 2.6 per cent from the previous year. Winter months are the strongest for Dubai hotels, with occupancy and prices falling to half their peaks by July.

 Get the latest information on credit cards, bank accounts and loan products in the UAE. Mark Lennihan / AP Photo

Rates report: Latest on UAE loans, accounts and credit cards

Souqamal.com brings you the latest interest rates on banking products in the UAE.

Events

To add your event to The National listings, click here

Get the most from The National