Text size:

  • Small
  • Normal
  • Large
At first sight the leaked allegations give credence to the view that the world is nearing 'peak oil'.
At first sight the leaked allegations give credence to the view that the world is nearing 'peak oil'.

Peak oil believers put their faith in leaky arguments

Are Saudi oil reserves Wikileaking away? A release from the whistle-blowing website quotes Dr Sadad al Husseini, a Saudi oil expert, as saying he believed the kingdom's oil reserves were overstated by 40 per cent.

Are Saudi oil reserves Wikileaking away? Last Tuesday, The Guardian newspaper in the UK continued its releases from the whistle-blowing website with a US diplomatic cable quoting Dr Sadad al Husseini, a Saudi oil expert, as saying he believed the kingdom's oil reserves were overstated by 40 per cent.

Dr al Husseini was the executive vice president for exploration and production at Saudi Aramco until his retirement in 2004, a move allegedly triggered by a failed attempt to elevate himself to chief executive.

His view, expressed to a US diplomat, was apparently that Aramco would be unable to meet its target of 12.5 million barrels per day (bpd) in sustainable capacity but with a huge investment effort, it could possibly produce 12 million bpd for some 15 years before inevitable decline set in.

So, at first sight, the leaked allegations give credence to those who argue the world is nearing "peak oil", the point at which reserves will become insufficient to keep production growing. Declining output in mature non-Opec areas such as the North Sea and Mexico leads most analysts to believe the world will become increasingly dependent on Opec supplies.

After Russia, Saudi Arabia is the world's largest producer, with almost 10 per cent of global output. And it holds the biggest conventional reserves, its official 265 billion barrels representing a fifth of the world's proved total.

If Opec's largest producer is unable to step up production significantly, then, so the argument goes, global oil output must be near a relentless decline. Thus the leaks have been hailed by peak oil believers. Yet these doubts about Saudi oil capacity are shaky in three ways.

First, the story is nothing new. Dr al Husseini has been perfectly open about his views since a 2002 conference in Jakarta. In 2004, he made similar points in The New York Times. In The Guardian's case, there simply is no leak, no cover-up, no revelation. What comes next - shock reports that North Korea is undemocratic?

Around 2004, others were also casting doubts on Saudi oil capacity. The most high-profile was the late Matthew Simmons, a US investment banker, who argued in his book Twilight in the Desert that the Saudis were facing serious technical problems in their fields.

The then Bank of Montreal analyst Don Coxe opined that "the kingdom's decline rate will be among the world's fastest as this decade wanes". Paul Roberts, a resources journalist, focused on alleged problems at the Saudis' largest field, Ghawar, in his book The End of Oil.

The writings of the three men were littered with elementary technical errors and misunderstandings of the industry that a professional could easily have corrected. Nor did they present much evidence, beyond cherry-picked anecdotes of ordinary problems that are faced and solved every day in oilfields around the world.

Experts such as the economist Michael Lynch convincingly rebutted their arguments. But the idea of Saudi oil decline entered the popular imagination, and has not been dislodged. Since oil prices did not jump on the Wikileaks story, it is clear that either the market already knew of these worries about Saudi reserves or does not believe them.

Second, Dr al Husseini's own views are much more complicated and nuanced than sensationalist headlines suggest. In 2004, in the respected Oil & Gas Journal, he wrote: "My staff and I were confident that Aramco could sustain even higher rates of production, if necessary." His concern about higher production was whether it was economically optimal, not technically feasible.

"The kingdom can certainly increase its production to 15 million bpd, based on its existing reserves," he added. Dr al Husseini said sustaining that level would require finding more reserves and using new technologies, which on past form seems certain to be achieved.

Third, Saudi Aramco's behaviour is not that of a company in crisis. When Oman's production went into decline in 2002, the sultanate stepped up exploration drilling, brought in new companies to reduce the near-monopoly of the state-controlled Petroleum Development Oman, started developing large heavy-oil fields, and launched a major effort in enhanced oil recovery (EOR) - a group of advanced technologies used to extract more oil from old fields.

By contrast, Saudi Arabia has just started some limited pilot projects in heavy oil and EOR. Even at full capacity, Saudi Arabia would be producing less than 2 per cent of its reserves a year - Oman's peak extraction rate was more than three times higher.

Exploration has recently been diverted away from looking for oil to focus on discovering more gas. Other experts, such as the now retired Abdullah al Saif, Dr al Husseini's successor, as well as Dr Nansen Saleri, the former head of Saudi reservoir management, have expressed great confidence in the kingdom's oil production.

And in 2009, the huge Khurais field started up, producing 1.2 million bpd of high-quality light oil at a reported cost of US$10 billion (Dh36.72bn). That sounds expensive - but consider that, at current prices, the investment would be recovered in less than three months.

Khurais and other expansions took Saudi capacity to the 12.5 million bpd mark mentioned by Dr al Husseini. The only reason the kingdom is not at that level today is because of its production cuts to support prices during the economic crisis.

And that is the pointer to Saudi production policy. Not a lack of reserves, but the desire to manage oil markets to maximise revenues. Having spent so lavishly to build unused capacity, the Saudis are naturally wary of launching new projects until they are sure of demand.

As they so often do, peak oil believers are ascribing too much importance to geology, and too little to economics.


Robin M Mills is an energy economist based in Dubai, and the author of The Myth of the Oil Crisis and Capturing Carbon

Back to the top

More articles

Editor's Picks

 Would you like it in blue? An Afghan shopkeeper shows a burqa to a customer at a bazaar in Herat. (Aref Karimi / AFP /  April 13, 2014)

In pictures: Best business images for the week to April 24, 2014

Here are some of the best business images for the week to April 24, 2014.

 That's asking a lot: this four-bedroom duplex penthouse apartment  at Marina Residence in Dubai is for sale with an asking price of Dh15.7 million. (Courtesy Better Homes / April 2014)

In pictures: Palm Jumeirah penthouse listed for Dh15.7 million

A four-bedroom duplex penthouse in Marina Residence 3 on Dubai's Palm Jumeirah is on the market for Dh15.7 million.

 Room with a view from one of the 21 duplex penthouses located in the Gate Towers sky-bridge. The sports courts and swimming pools can be seen below. Courtesy Alda

In pictures: Aldar’s Gate Towers Penthouse Collection on Reem Island

Aldar launched its Gate Towers Penthouse Collection at Cityscape Abu Dhabi. The launch features 21 penthouses spanning the skybridge, with each having a private indoor pool and incredible views.

 Marina Square apartments Reem Island: Q1 2% rise. Studio - Dh65-68,000. 1BR - Dh75-95,000. 2BR - Dh110-145,000. 3BR - Dh170-190,000. Q1 2013-Q1 2014 no change. Sammy Dallal / The National

In pictures: Where Abu Dhabi rents have risen and fallen, Q1 2014

Find out how rental prices in the prime locations in Abu Dhabi have altered during the first three months of the year and the current rates you will pay according to data provided by Asteco.

 The Wind, Energy, Technology and Environment Exhibition takes place from April 14 to April 16. Above, the Dewa showroom during last year’s Wetex. Jaime Puebla / The National

April corporate and economic calendar for the UAE and overseas

From Cityscape to Wetex to stock-market holidays to nations reporting first-quarter GDP figures, here is our helpful calendar of April's business events in the UAE and internationally.

 Get the latest information on credit cards, bank accounts and loan products in the UAE. Mark Lennihan / AP Photo

Rates report: Latest on UAE loans, accounts and credit cards

Souqamal.com brings you the latest interest rates on banking products in the UAE.


To add your event to The National listings, click here

Get the most from The National