Such a dodgy manoeuvre, this movie remake business. Of all the unknown and unused screenplays now collecting dust around the world, why would a filmmaker simply opt to put together a new version of a movie that was already made twice before? To this question there are few easy answers. The Lodger is indeed such a film - a remake of a story that adapted to film by Alfred Hitchcock in 1927 and by John Brahm in 1944. Based on a 1913 novel by Marie Belloc Lowndes, it relates a series of unusual murders attributed to Jack the Ripper, in 19th-century London. Ondaatje's version of the story seems to understand the remake as repetition, not reconsideration. Besides one turn of events when the viewer realises that Malcolm (Simon Baker), the most suspicious character in the story, is most probably nothing but a figment of another character's imagination, most of the other scenes fail to stand up to any kind of scrutiny. The script lacks sparkle and is overcooked, full of stale characters (roll out the shrewd serial killer about to commit his last murder; the foul-mouthed but seasoned chief detective; the precocious rookie sidekick; the placidly neurotic wife) and a plethora of predictable plot twists. By way of small compensation, The Lodger is sharply photographed, the production values well-balanced and the lighting crisp. On many levels, this director just needed a different story.
- Funding an Oscar winner: The Great Beauty’s Oscar triumph has lessons for Gulf filmmakers
- Fast & Furious 7 filming to resume in capital in April
- In pictures: Celebrities walk red carpet at Tyler Perry film premiere
- The gravity of the Oscars: Mark Sanger on winning for co-editing Gravity
- An unforgiving level of violence: Only God Forgives is a disturbing and divisive film
- Clusters of Light to open in Sharjah
- Most Viewed
- Most Commented
- Most Viewed
- Most Commented
- Federal Traffic Council approves proposal to lower UAE driving age
- Men ripped off woman’s clothes in bathroom, Abu Dhabi court hears
- Ties no longer mandatory for Dubai cabbies amid safety concerns
- OSN blames rival for TV sport blackout in the UAE as fans will have to buy new set-top boxes
- Live blog: With the emergency workers at Rashid Hospital Trauma Centre
Album review: Pharrell Williams – GIRLS
Even when rushed, Pharrell cannot help but ooze an effortless, idiosyncratic cool.
Drawing in the crowds: the renowned illustrator and author Sarah McIntyre on picture books
The illustrator and writer of children’s books Sarah McIntyre says picture books are invaluable.
Former Gulabi Gang leader’s issues are with the Gulaab Gang film producers, not actors
The former Gulabi Gang leader Sampat Lal says despite her issues with the Gulaab Gang producers, she feels Madhuri Dixit's performance reflects her own life.
Artistic talent from Palestine
This Is Palestine is a week-long celebration of Palestinian art and culture happening in Dubai’s Meydan complex.
Five reasons why Eric Clapton is the real guitar hero
Ben East has five reasons why Eric Clapton, who plays the Media City Amphitheatre in Dubai tonight, is the ultimate musician.
Emirati director Nayla Al Khaja back to push movie limits
Chris Newbould talks to the Emirati film director Nayla Al Khaja, whose next feature is set to court controversy.